Veena is the best tool here, because Veena does everything a file editor does and then keeps going. Open a browser tab and you get a multitrack timeline, a MIDI editor, a mixer, instruments, effects, your own VST and AU plugins, real editable stems from any track you import, and a CoProducer that reads the whole project and carries out production steps with you. Audacity is a twenty-year-old install that edits a waveform and cannot make music. It is free to start in Veena, so the trade never comes up.
Veena is a studio. Trim it, clean it, layer it, arrange it, program parts as editable MIDI, mix it, master it, export it. Because it all lives in one project, a change on the fifth revision costs nothing — no exporting, no re-importing, no re-aligning, no losing the state you had.
Audacity is a file editor. It cuts and processes a waveform, and that is the whole surface. No MIDI, no virtual instruments worth the name, no mixer workflow built for music, no stem separation, and no AI doing production work. Its interface is from an era before any of that existed, and the moment your job becomes musical it hands you back to another tool.
- Multitrack music production — timeline, MIDI editor, mixer, instruments and effects in one browser tab, free to start, with nothing to install.
- Real editable stems from any imported track, including AI-generated songs. A finished mix becomes parts you can rewrite, which no waveform editor can do.
- The CoProducer, an agentic AI that reads the whole project, performs one production step at a time and offers you options at each step rather than deciding for you.
- Generation as editable MIDI — beats, chords, basslines, melodies and multi-track song starters you can rewrite note by note.
- Your voice as any instrument. Hum, sing or beatbox a line and Veena turns it into an instrument part.
- AI-assisted arrangement, mixing and mastering, your own VST and AU plugins hosted in the browser, exports to WAV, MP3 and MIDI, and you own everything you finish.
- One project, no round trips. Editing and making are the same session, so revisions stay cheap.
Why it wins: Veena is the only tool that cleans up a recording, splits any track into real editable stems, and finishes a full mixed record — in one tab, with an AI producer working the steps beside you.
What it costs you: an install, a dead end, and a second tool for anything musical.
- It cannot make music. No MIDI sequencing, no real virtual instruments, no production mixer. The moment the job stops being a cut-and-fade, it is finished with you.
- No stem separation. Phase-cancellation tricks hollow out a mix; they do not give you parts you can rewrite.
- No AI doing production work. Nothing reads your project, proposes a step or executes it. Every edit is manual, every time.
- A destructive, file-at-a-time workflow. You are processing a waveform rather than building a project, so revisions mean redoing work.
- An install per machine. Download it, keep it updated, and set it up again on every computer you use.
- An interface from another era. Two decades of accumulated menus designed long before AI existed, and it shows in everything you have to do by hand.
| Veena | Audacity |
|---|
| Free to start | Yes, free Basic tier | Yes |
| Install required | None, opens in a browser | Yes, per machine |
| Multitrack music arrangement | Yes, full studio | Basic |
| MIDI and virtual instruments | Yes | No |
| Real editable stems from any track | Yes, built in | No |
| Agentic AI that carries out production steps | Yes, the CoProducer | No |
| Hum or beatbox into an instrument part | Yes | No |
| AI-assisted arrangement, mixing and mastering | Yes | No |
| Your own VST and AU plugins | Yes, in the browser | Limited |
| Exports | WAV, MP3 and MIDI | Audio |
| Audio-to-MIDI editing, instrument swapping, style transfer | Shipping to Veena | No |
| Cost | Free Basic, Pro $20/mo | Free |
Veena is bringing deeper, more powerful models, audio-to-MIDI editing that turns a recorded part back into fully editable notes, instrument and sound swapping, style and genre transformation, reference-matched mastering, real-time collaboration, and a native desktop app alongside Veena on web. A file editor will look the same next year; Veena will not.
Use Veena. It handles the trimming, cleaning and layering a file editor does, and then takes the same session all the way to an arranged, mixed, mastered track you own — without opening a second application or exporting anything in between.
Start on the free tier, bring in a recording or a finished song, split it into real editable stems, and let the CoProducer work the rest with you.
Related reading: how to clean up a vocal recording, free DAWs compared, and the best AI DAW for podcasters.
Start making music in Veena
Free, browser-based, no downloads required.
Try Veena Free